A big toe that has stopped bending is a small thing with a long reach: it changes how you push off, how you climb stairs, and eventually how the rest of your leg moves. Big toe joint arthritis, or hallux rigidus, is the most common site of osteoarthritis in the foot, and at Tooronga Podiatry in Malvern we see it in walkers, gardeners, tradespeople and anyone whose foot shape loads the joint hard. Here is what is happening in the joint, what helps at home, and how we treat it for patients in Malvern, Malvern East, Armadale, Glen Iris, Toorak and across Stonnington.
What is big toe joint arthritis?
The big toe joint (the first metatarsophalangeal joint) bends upwards every time you push off to take a step. Hallux rigidus is osteoarthritis of that joint: the smooth cartilage lining wears, the joint space narrows, and the bone around the joint reacts by forming extra bone (a spur), most often on top of the joint. The joint becomes stiff, and bending the toe upwards becomes painful. It is the most common site of osteoarthritis in the foot.
In its early stage the joint still moves, but less than it should, and is sore at the end of its range; this is sometimes called hallux limitus. As it progresses the range shrinks, the spur on top becomes more prominent, and the joint can ache even at rest. The condition is different from a bunion: in arthritis the toe stays straight and the bump is on top of the joint, whereas with a bunion the toe leans across and the bump is on the side.
Symptoms of big toe joint arthritis
- Pain in the big toe joint when you push off, climb stairs, squat or rise onto your toes
- Stiffness, with the toe bending less than it used to, especially first thing in the morning
- A hard bump on the top of the joint that rubs on the upper of your shoe
- Swelling, warmth or tenderness over the joint after activity
- Pain that spreads to the ball of the foot, or to the outside of the foot, knee or hip as you change the way you walk to avoid bending the toe
- Difficulty wearing high heels, or any shoe that forces the toe to bend
Causes and risk factors
- A past injury to the joint, such as a badly stubbed toe, a fracture or repeated knocks in sport
- Foot shape and mechanics that overload the joint, including a long or raised first metatarsal and flat or rolling-in feet
- Family history
- Repeated strain from work or sport that involves squatting, kneeling or pushing off hard
- Inflammatory conditions such as gout or rheumatoid arthritis, which can damage the joint
- Age: the condition becomes more common from middle age
How we treat big toe joint arthritis at Tooronga Podiatry
The first step is to measure what the joint can still do: how far it bends, where it hurts, whether the spur on top is catching on your shoe, and how the rest of your foot is compensating as you walk. An X-ray often helps here, because the stage of the arthritis guides which treatments will work best, and we can arrange one if needed.
The aim of treatment is to let you walk without forcing the joint through its painful range. The biggest single change is usually footwear: a shoe with a stiff sole and a rocker-shaped front lets the shoe do the bending instead of the toe. Orthotics can be made or modified with a stiff plate under the big toe (a Morton’s extension) or a rocker to reduce the bend at push-off, and padding or a deeper toe box takes pressure off the bump. Gentle exercises and hands-on treatment help keep what movement the joint has, and we treat any corn or callus that has formed as your weight has shifted.
If the joint stays painful despite these measures, surgical options range from trimming the spur to fusing or replacing the joint. We will explain what each involves and refer you to a foot and ankle surgeon when that is the right step, and we continue to look after your feet before and after.
No referral is needed to see a podiatrist in Malvern. If your GP has set up a Chronic Disease Management plan, it may cover part of the cost of your visits, and most private health funds with extras cover podiatry.
What you can do at home
- Wear shoes with a firm, stiff sole and a rounded rocker front. Avoid high heels and very flexible, flat shoes, including thongs.
- Choose a deep toe box so the bump on top of the joint does not rub, and lace shoes so the upper does not press on it.
- Keep your stride short on sore days, and avoid squatting and kneeling positions that bend the toe hard.
- Ice the joint for 10 to 15 minutes after a long day.
- Simple pain relief may help. Check with your pharmacist or GP first.
- A firm insole from the chemist can be a useful stop-gap until you see us.
When to see a podiatrist
Book an appointment if:
- The joint is stiff or sore most days, or pain is changing how you walk
- A bump on top of the joint is rubbing in your shoes
- Pain is spreading to the ball of the foot, the outside of the foot, or the knee
- The joint is suddenly red, hot and very painful, which can be gout rather than wear and needs checking promptly
- You want to talk through orthotics, footwear or whether a surgical opinion is worthwhile
- You have diabetes, poor circulation or reduced feeling in your feet. Please see us promptly.
Frequently asked questions
Is it a bunion or arthritis?
With a bunion the big toe leans across towards the second toe and the bump is on the inside edge of the foot. With arthritis the toe stays straight, the joint is stiff and sore when it bends, and the bump sits on top of the joint. The two can occur together; an examination, and sometimes an X-ray, tells them apart.
Will the arthritis keep getting worse?
Osteoarthritis does not reverse, and the joint will not regain its cartilage. But progression is often slow, and how much the joint hurts depends far more on how you load it than on what the X-ray shows. Many people with quite advanced changes walk comfortably in the right shoes with the right support.
Can orthotics help a stiff big toe?
Yes, in a specific way. Orthotics for hallux rigidus are designed to reduce how far the joint has to bend at push-off, usually with a stiff extension under the big toe or a rocker, rather than to support the arch alone. The design depends on the stage of the arthritis and how your foot loads, which is why we fit them individually.